ESR-REIT downgraded to 'hold' on potential rental default from Hyflux Membrane

ESR-REIT downgraded to 'hold' on potential rental default from Hyflux Membrane

By: 
Samantha Chiew
10/04/19, 04:55 pm

SINGAPORE (Apr 10): ESR-REIT has been downgraded to “hold” from “buy” previously by OCBC Investment Research with a decreased fair value of 55 cents from 57.5 cents, on the back of lower returns and concerns regarding Hyflux Membrane.

The research house initiated its coverage on ESR-REIT on Dec 14, 2018 and the stock has since posted total returns of 9.76%, compared to the Straits Times Index’s 7.41%. It still continues to trade at a discount to industrial REITs that also have large portfolios, but this has narrowed significantly since the research house’s initiation.

ESR-REIT also has a relatively high net gearing ratio of 41.9%, which increases its risk of a dilutive equity financing.

At yesterday’s close, the REIT traded at 1.17 times price-to-book, compared to the 1.33 times average of its large portfolio peers. It also has a dividend yield of 7.0% FY19 yield.

In a Wednesday report, analyst Deborah Ong says, “We note that Hyflux Membrane is one of ESR-REIT’s top 10 tenants, accounting for about 3.5% of the total rental income for Dec 2018 and about 7.2% of distributable income for 4Q18.”

Recently, Hyflux has filed for bankruptcy protection. And the analyst has expressed her concerns about ESR-REIT’s exposure to Hyflux. Hyflux Membrane is one of ESR-REIT’s top 10 tenants, accounting for about 3.5% of the total rental income for Dec 2018 and about 7.2% of distributable income for 4Q18.

With this, Ong has identified several mitigating factors for ESR-REIT:

  • Hyflux Membrane has not defaulted in its rental payments
  • Should Hyflux’s business remain intact after the restructuring, she believes there is still a good chance that Hyflux Membrane will continue to rent its current premises (8 Tuas South Lane)
  • The asset is within an established industrial area and ESR-REIT has been receiving leasing interest and enquiries for the space
  • ESR-REIT presently holds security deposits worth three months of rental income, which have yet to be drawn down

“That said, in the case of a default, we believe the asset will be subject to JTC anchor tenant rules which may be onerous to fulfil,” adds Ong.

Nonetheless, property forecasts have been updated to account for a potential Hyflux Membrane rental default.

Looking ahead, a bottoming in industrial rents in 2019 is to be expected, though towards the latter half of the year given the backend-loaded supply injection last year.

Units in ESR-REIT closed at 53 cents on Wednesday.

US sanctions on Huawei could backfire

SINGAPORE (May 27): It was only to have been expected. After nearly a year of pressure that failed to stop Huawei Technologies Co’s expansion -- especially in the rollout of the next generation 5G wireless network globally -- in its tracks, US President Donald Trump signed an executive order effectively barring American firms from doing business with the Chinese telecommunications equipment company. The inclusion of Huawei on the US Department of Commerce’s Bureau of Industry and Security’s (BIS) Entity List means that companies would need to apply for a waiver to supply goods with 25....
Read More >>

Annica chairman Ong quits just as $33 mil goes missing at his law firm JLC

SINGAPORE (May 27): Jeffrey Ong, managing partner of law firm JLC Advisors, may have given instructions to pay out a sum of $33.2 million held in escrow by his firm for a client, Allied Technologies. According to Allied’s statement filed with Singapore Exchange on May 23, the payment may have been “unauthorised”, citing a letter it received from JLC on May 22. Allied’s statement did not specify who the payment was made to. Ong also abruptly resigned as non-executive chairman of Annica Holdings on May 20. In a May 22 filing with SGX, Annica CEO Sandra Liz Hon Ai Ling said Ong resigne....
Read More >>

SGX RegCo sees targeted approach in enforcement, more powerful market discipline

SINGAPORE (May 27): Tan Boon Gin, CEO of stock exchange regulator Singapore Exchange Regulation, says the market can expect a stronger regulatory presence. “You will see a series of enforcement cases coming up quite soon,” he tells The Edge Singapore. Tan’s assertion comes amid significant changes in the market as sentiment remains lacklustre and investors’ expectations change. The local stock market has gone through significant upheaval, not least because of the penny stock crash in 2013 that wiped out some $8 billion in value from the market. The event dented investor sentiment, a....
Read More >>