CityDev's privatisation bid for M&C bodes well for both, with or without deal: Phillip Capital

CityDev's privatisation bid for M&C bodes well for both, with or without deal: Phillip Capital

Michelle Zhu
12/12/17, 12:47 pm

SINGAPORE (Dec 12): Phillip Capital is maintaining its “accumulate” rating on City Developments (CityDev) with a target price of $12.10, after the group announced its final takeover offer for the remaining shares of Millennium & Copthorne (M&C) it doesn’t own.

In a Tuesday report, analyst Dehong Tan notes that the new offer of 620 pence per share is 12% higher than previously, and represents an attractive value for CityDev as it is pegged to 0.75 times book value despite it being at a 39% premium to the pre-offer last close price.

The privatisation of M&C is to be RNAV-accretive to CityDev if the deal goes through, adds the analyst, who calculates that the consolidation will lift CityDev’s RNAV by about 10.6% to $15.75 per share with a corresponding adjusted target price of $13.39.

Tan says he remains positive on CityDev regardless of whether the privatisation goes through, as CityDev already owns a majority 65% stake in M&C.

While the successful privatisation of M&C will result in a nimbler company and “tremendous monetisation potential”, in Tan’s view, he opines that the offer would have provided reasonable support to the trading price of M&C such that it is unlikely prices will fall back to the pre-offer valuation of 0.55 times NAV.

“Due to the intensive capital requirement and low-returns nature of the business, M&C has historically traded at a sizable discount to its book. Even with its hotels carried at cost, the highest valuation M&C traded at in the past decade post GFC was still a 7% discount to book. Without a clear monetisation strategy for its assets, investors hoping for an exit opportunity at a significant premium to book value could be in for a prolonged wait,” explains the analyst.  

“We note that the offer price is close to average post-GFC P/BV valuation of 0.74 for M&C. However, the offer price also represents a discount to the average valuation of 0.98x P/BV for M&C’s locally listed peers who are hotel operators with similar asset-heavy balance sheets and most self-owned hotels,” he adds.

Meanwhile, CIMB has kept its "add" rating on the stock with an unchanged price target of $13.15, on expectations of a potential 5% to projected RNAV for CityDev should full ownership of M&C be obtained. 

Its analyst Lock Mun Yee notes that the transaction could raise the group's gearing to 0.31 times versus 0.13 times as at 3Q17, causing post-transaction earnings and NTA to increase on a pro-forma basis by 7% and 1.5%, respectively. 

"We leave our current earnings and RNAV estimates unchanged for now, pending the successful completion of this exercise. CityDev’s share price has retraced 12% from the recent Oct high and is currently trading at close to the pre-initial announcement level. We believe the current share price has not reflected any potential accretion from this transaction,” says Lock. 

As at 12.47pm, shares in CityDev are trading 6 cents lower at $12.51. 

Counsels argue over how witnesses' conditioned statements were prepared and used

SINGAPORE (May 23): The prosecution and defence in the 2013 penny stock crash trial on Thursday crossed swords over how conditioned statements had been prepared, and the relevancy of questions raised in cross-examination of these statements. Deputy public prosecutor Peter Koy said questions by the defence counsels for alleged co-conspirators John Soh Chee Wen and Quah Su-Ling were a “distraction from the facts”. “Questions as to what was shown to the witness, what trade and telephone data were shown to the witness, which data was filtered and shown to the witness, are irrelevant to....

Boustead Projects records 2% dip in 4Q earnings to $5.7 mil despite revenue surge

SINGAPORE (May 23): Real estate solutions specialist Boustead Projects posted a 2% drop in earnings to $5.7 million for the 4Q19 ended March, compared to restated earnings of $5.8 million for 4Q18. This brings full year earnings for FY19 to $30.6 million, some 5% higher than earnings of $29.2 million a year ago. The group recorded earnings per share (EPS) of 1.8 cents for 4Q19, the same as a year ago. For FY19, EPS rose to 9.8 cents, compared to 9.1 cents for FY18. The decline in 4Q earnings was mainly due to lower gross margins in design-and-build projects and depreciation incurred o....

Sunpower wins $8.7 mil contract from repeat customer

SINGAPORE (May 23): Sunpower Group, the environmental protection solutions specialist, has signed a RMB43.56 million ($8.7 million) contract with repeat customer Zhejiang Petrochemical Co. Sunpower will provide high-efficiency heat exchangers for one of China’s largest domestic atmospheric and vacuum pressure units with an annual capacity of 10 million tons, which is part of Phase 2 of Zhejiang Petrochemical’s refinery and chemical integration project. The project is part of China’s 13th Five-Year National Petroleum and Chemical Plan. Sunpower started its partnership with Zhengj....