On the morning of June 8, the REIT manager announced that it had received a letter from activist investor Quarz Capital Asia the day before.

The letter suggested that the REIT appoint an internal manager as well as “qualified candidates” of the internal manager.

Quarz Capital currently has a 13.19% stake in Sabana REIT after <a href="https://www.theedgesingapore.com/news/offer/volares-partial-offer-sabana-reit-turns-unconditional" target="_blank">tendering some 29.4 million units – or a 2.67% stake – to Volare Group AG</a> on April 5. Volare, a Swiss entity that took a 5% stake in the REIT in 2022, had made a <a href="https://www.theedgesingapore.com/news/offer/volare-makes-partial-offer-sabana-reits-unitholders" target="_blank">partial offer for a 10% stake in the REIT</a> at 46.5 cents per unit on Jan 20. Prior to its disposal, Quarz Capital held a 15.86% stake in Sabana REIT.

In its note dated June 8, the DBS team referred to the previous REIT, Croesus Retail Trust, that had internalised its own manager in 2016. The trust’s assets were gradually divested and it was eventually delisted.

“This could potentially happen again if the internalisation of manager does happen, and we question if such an option to dissolve its portfolio is indeed the ideal scenario to maximise returns for shareholders,” says DBS.

See also: <a class='gtm_see_also_1_inread' style='text-decoration: underline;' href='/news/reits/sabana-trustee-disagrees-suggestion-wrongdoing-or-delay-its-part?utm_source=website&utm_medium=article&utm_campaign=ONPAGESEO'>Sabana Trustee disagrees with suggestion of wrongdoing or delay on its part</a>

“We also ask ourselves if this will spark a rethink for Singapore REITs (S-REITs) and the debate on whether internally managed S-REITs would work and if the benefits outweigh that of the current externally managed model,” it adds.

While the team acknowledges that there are some benefits to an internal REIT manager, it also notes that the move may be counter-productive to Sabana REIT considering its smaller portfolio size of $886 million of assets under management (AUM).

“The REIT currently lacks the scale to benefit from economies of scale. Especially on the onset, more costs may be incurred to create the necessary infrastructure for an internal manager,” the team notes.

See also: <a class='gtm_see_also_2_inread' style='text-decoration: underline;' href='/news/reits/clct-net-rmb6907-million-divestment-beijing-mall?utm_source=website&utm_medium=article&utm_campaign=ONPAGESEO'>CLCT to net RMB690.7 million from divestment of Beijing mall</a>

“Moreover, one of the major proponents of an internal manager is that the manager will be entirely focused on just the one portfolio and will benefit from the added focus. However, Sabana REIT currently does not have a sponsor or other subsidiary vehicles that they manage, and would already be exclusively focused on managing Sabana REIT,” it adds.

On whether an internally-managed REIT would work well for S-REITs, DBS sees that Sabana REIT is in a “more unique situation” compared to its peers as it is not backed by a strong sponsor. The REIT is not part of a bigger group that provides acquisition pipelines and management support either.

“As part of a larger group, the sponsor would be committed to grow the REIT and maximise returns for shareholders. We believe this is one of the major benefits of the externally managed REIT model that cannot be simply measured in cost savings derived from internalising the REIT manager,” says DBS. “The commitment and support from the sponsor provides the REIT with more intrinsic value over the finite dollar amount that could potentially be saved.”

DBS has kept its “hold” call with an unchanged target price of 48 cents on the REIT.

As at 4.15pm, units in Sabana REIT are trading 0.5 cents lower or 1.16% down at 42.5 cents.

Internalisation of property management costs may be counter-productive for Sabana REIT, says DBS

US stock faithful ride US$7 trillion rally as market timing backfires

Qarbotech named winner of inaugural EQT Impact Challenge

MSCI boss warns of climate risks

Keppel to acquire 50% stake in European asset manager Aermont Capital for up to $517 mil

Internalisation of property management costs may be counter-productive for Sabana REIT, says DBS

Related News

Highlights

US stock faithful ride US$7 trillion rally as market timing backfires

Related News

Banks, industrials, tech and telcos to benefit from adoption of GenAI: Maybank

Is it time to add into S-REITs despite the sector's 7% gain in November?

UOB Kay Hian lowers MPACT’s TP, DPU on lower contributions from China and further depreciation on forex