Continue reading this on our app for a better experience

Open in App
Home Capital Broker's Calls

Uncertainties remain for Noble even with FY17 profitability in sight

Michelle Zhu
Michelle Zhu • 2 min read
Uncertainties remain for Noble even with FY17 profitability in sight
SINGAPORE (Feb 28): DBS Vickers Securities is keeping its “hold” call on Noble Group while raising its target price to 23 cents from 20 cents previously – on the belief that a further re-rating beyond the stock’s current level is “unjustified”
Font Resizer
Share to Whatsapp
Share to Facebook
Share to LinkedIn
Scroll to top
Follow us on Facebook and join our Telegram channel for the latest updates.

SINGAPORE (Feb 28): DBS Vickers Securities is keeping its “hold” call on Noble Group while raising its target price to 23 cents from 20 cents previously – on the belief that a further re-rating beyond the stock’s current level is “unjustified” without details over Sinochem’s potential investment in the group, and/or a material improvement in free cashflow generation.

To recap, sources told Reuters this month that China’s state-owned Sinochem is in discussion about the possible purchase of an equity stake in Noble, which the commodity firm later on confirmed.

This was followed by the release of a critical report from Iceberg Research, which said Noble was not worth its book value and hence questioned Noble’s accounting practices.

(See also: Noble shares plunge after Iceberg questions Sinochem deal prospects)

“While Sinochem is in discussions with Noble, we believe it is still too early to ascribe a value to the balance sheet items which the market has been questioning for the past two years (i.e. for a re-rating above c.S$0.23), given risk that Sinochem may withdraw, lack of details over structure of any transaction and the carrying value of these assets still falling,” elaborates analyst Mervyn Song in a Tuesday report.

While Song expects the group to return to profitability in FY17 as it is no longer constrained by the need to preserve liquidity, the analyst believes a sustained re-rating on the stock will be “difficult”, given its potential negative free cashflows resulting from the need to build up inventories.

More importantly, he points out that a major obstacle would be the questions raised by Iceberg on quality of the group’s earnings statement, as its FY16 profits were boosted by US$126 million gains on level 3 assets whose valuations were based on inputs determined by the company itself.

(See also: Noble Group swings back to black in FY16 with earnings of US$8.7 mil)

“Nevertheless, as Noble gets back to business, we expect operating cashflows to remain negative as it rebuilds its inventory position. This may place a cap on Noble’s share price performance,” adds Song.

As at 12.26pm, shares of Noble are trading flat at 23 cents.

×
Loading next article...
The Edge Singapore
Download The Edge Singapore App
Google playApple store play
Keep updated
Follow our social media
© 2024 The Edge Publishing Pte Ltd. All rights reserved.